CLAThacker
don't just crack CLAT, come hack CLAT with us.
logical and critical reasoning:-post ur doubts
gyus and gals plzzz post ur doubt here
Started by :-TANMAYEE SAHOO
Started by :-TANMAYEE SAHOO
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Ramanuj Mukherjee on -
avinash and apoorva: there is no need to fight. you may disagree on an answer or reasoning - but it is very kiddish to fight. lets not go into whose fault it is or who started it, but please do not divert from the topic!
i shall take a look at the question and soon post my reply.
-
Permalink Reply by Avinash Kumar on -
@ris.. bro.. there z a rule saying that- " if more than one statement seem to contradict or weaken an argument, the one that weakens or contradicts the basic assumption of the argument would be the most weakening."
thats why i pointed out the basic assumtion; which i have already mentioned, and the argument contradicting dat was referred to be d most weakening argument by me..
-
Permalink Reply by kaivalya kandarpa on -
in that case i agree with you....
i totally misinterpreted the situation(though i got the answer!)
Hehe "to err is to human"! :)
avinash said:@ris.. bro.. there z a rule saying that- " if more than one statement seem to contradict or weaken an argument, the one that weakens or contradicts the basic assumption of the argument would be the most weakening."
thats why i pointed out the basic assumtion; which i have already mentioned, and the argument contradicting dat was referred to be d most weakening argument by me..
-
Permalink Reply by tanmayee sahoo on -
STATEMANT: No system are decks.
All decks are books.
CONCLUSION:i some system are books
ii some system are not books.
iii some books are system
iv some books are not system.
1) Only II Follows 3) II and IV follows
2)Only IV follows 4) I and either III or IV
5) Either I or II and IV follows
-
Permalink Reply by Avinash Kumar on
-
after making all the three possible venn diagrams, answer will be option 2.. only 4 follows
tanmayee sahoo said:STATEMANT: No system are decks.
All decks are books.
CONCLUSION:i some system are books
ii some system are not books.
iii some books are system
iv some books are not system.
1) Only II Follows 3) II and IV follows
2)Only IV follows 4) I and either III or IV
5) Either I or II and IV follows
-
Permalink Reply by kaivalya kandarpa on
-
yah apoorva you dont actually need to do this for such trivial a thing,but since you have decided,wish you good luck!
you have a great g.k.-i must say
and yes we will miss your insights! :)
-
Permalink Reply by Avinash Kumar on
-
oye... dont leave... use brains.. not heart.. if so small word exchanges can hurt u so much, itz not gud.. gal!!! 1 has 2 face many such disputes in lyf... be brave!!! come-on!! smile now :)
Apoorva sharma said:thanks.
avinash said:no need 2 take any decision in anger..anyaway!! okay.. good luck... may we see u topping next year!! and me being d second...hehehehehehe
Apoorva sharma said:I'm leaving the site, this will be my last comment. BYE
avinash said:apoorva...first of all; i din't intend 2 make anybody's mockery! i cant help if somebody misinterpretes my words!!! and ya.. if making a mockery leads 2 anybody's decline , den thinking bad for others also leads 2 decline of dat person :) .. don't forget dat!! :)
lets end d duel.. moreover we both had already apologised 2 each other..... anyway!! we r here 2 gain something rather dan wasting tym in useless dialogues!! at least one person will have 2 pull down..and lemme do dat... and now lets forget d fyt...
-
Permalink Reply by Avinash Kumar on
-
yeah..its 4 only
Apoorva sharma said:2].Only IV follows
tanmayee sahoo said:STATEMANT: No system are decks.
All decks are books.
CONCLUSION:i some system are books
ii some system are not books.
iii some books are system
iv some books are not system.
1) Only II Follows 3) II and IV follows
2)Only IV follows 4) I and either III or IV
5) Either I or II and IV follows
-
Permalink Reply by kaivalya kandarpa on
-
Well said avinash but mind you!she is not backing off-that was just a passing phase.she is wise enough not to leave us(friends) just because of a small misunderstanding! :)
@apoorva:well, though i bade you goodbye,i didnt mean it!we certainly dont want you to leave! :-)
avinash said:oye... dont leave... use brains.. not heart.. if so small word exchanges can hurt u so much, itz not gud.. gal!!! 1 has 2 face many such disputes in lyf... be brave!!! come-on!! smile now :)
Apoorva sharma said:thanks.
avinash said:no need 2 take any decision in anger..anyaway!! okay.. good luck... may we see u topping next year!! and me being d second...hehehehehehe
Apoorva sharma said:I'm leaving the site, this will be my last comment. BYE
avinash said:apoorva...first of all; i din't intend 2 make anybody's mockery! i cant help if somebody misinterpretes my words!!! and ya.. if making a mockery leads 2 anybody's decline , den thinking bad for others also leads 2 decline of dat person :) .. don't forget dat!! :)
lets end d duel.. moreover we both had already apologised 2 each other..... anyway!! we r here 2 gain something rather dan wasting tym in useless dialogues!! at least one person will have 2 pull down..and lemme do dat... and now lets forget d fyt...
-
Permalink Reply by Avinash Kumar on
-
Statements- All boxes are pans.
Some boxes are jugs.
some jugs are glasses.
Conclusions- 1. some glasses are boxes.
2.no glass is box
3. some jugs are pans
4. no jug is pan.
a. only 1 and 2 follow
b.either 1 or 2, and 3 follow
c. only 3 follows
d.either 1 or 2, and either 3 or 4 follow
e. none of dese
-
Permalink Reply by Avinash Kumar on
-
i m getting d ans. as C- only 3 follows.. but d given ans. z different.. please check out if u people get something else!!
avinash said:Statements- All boxes are pans.
Some boxes are jugs.
some jugs are glasses.
Conclusions- 1. some glasses are boxes.
2.no glass is box
3. some jugs are pans
4. no jug is pan.
a. only 1 and 2 follow
b.either 1 or 2, and 3 follow
c. only 3 follows
d.either 1 or 2, and either 3 or 4 follow
e. none of dese
-
Permalink Reply by kaivalya kandarpa on
-
yup i think the answer should be c!
Have Your Doubts Cleared!
It is never good to have doubts in your mind! Just ask a questions and the super intelligent CLAThackers, many of whom are writing CLAT this time and others who have cleared it already will answer your questions!
If you have doubts on logical reasoning or critical reasoning, ask here.
Legal reasoning doubts are answered on this thread!
Want to ask a GK question? try this thread!
Photos
Do you like CLAThacker?
© 2018 Created by Ramanuj Mukherjee.
Powered by
